Putting the pieces together, the most reasonable explanation is that the snap functioned akin to transporters inStar Trek. Spoiler Alert! But in those timelines - and probably in the majority of those 14 million futures - Doctor Strange was never restored. Avengers: Endgame ended with Tony Stark stealing the Infinity Stones from Thanos, and forming his own Infinity Gauntlet. I felt like at that moment when Strange lifts up his finger Tony finally got it. Answer: only if the dustings started before the Snap. Tom Bacon is Head of Screen Rant's Star Wars coverage. Why does Tony have to snap Thanos and his army to death, wouldn't that create a massive paradox in the timeline because then the original snap wouldn't have happened and cause massive parallel timelines like the ancient one said it wouldSo why couldn't have Tony snapped Thanos back to original point in time with the knowledge that it will a. The Marvel Cinematic Universe reached its peak with Avengers: Infinity War, which brought together all the current superheroes to stop Thanos from collecting all the Infinity Stones, and Avengers: Endgame, where the surviving heroes reversed the snap and defeated the Mad Titan once and for all. Why Thanos Didn't Just Kill All of the Avengers in Infinity War - CBR Another theory is that the souls were transported to the Quantum Realm, explaining why it was flooded with energy at the moment Thanos snapped his fingers. Why risk it? Then again, the Avengers cant save everyone, and previous films are a testament to that. Much improved. The place to drop your theories and memes about the MCU. Published May 22, 2019 A subtle detail in Avengers: Infinity War hints that the snap didn't really kill anyone at all - and implies that Thanos isn't dead. All Rights Reserved. Shockingly, Thanos proved to be the one villain who truly succeeded in his goal, and inAvengers: Endgame, he died content. Did Tony really kill Thanos at the end of Avengers Endgame There's been intense speculation as to whether or not Thanos actually died, though, and whether he could potentially return. It took the power of the Infinity Gauntlet to undo Thanos' snap, but it might be easier to reverse Tony Stark's. After all, Thanos affected the entire universe, whereas Tony's was geographically limited and erased a far smaller number of beings and objects from existence. It almost killed him. I'm assuming Tony fixed all time problems with his snap then the only thing left would be Cap as far as time plot holes go https://www.reddit.com/r/AvengersEndGame/comments/bhzel3/thoughts_on_captain_america_actual_endgame/?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share. Related: Avengers: Age of Ultron Foreshadowed Thor's Infinity War Failure. He's the creator and author of Collider's "How the MCU Was Made" series and has interviewed Bill Hader about every single episode of Barry. Is how the authors sees it. That's the point I was making. Todays deals: $4.50 smart plugs, $100 off AirPods Max, $65 smart TV, GE Opal ice makers, more. When Thanos is about to kill Iron Man, Dr. This would also show why Thanos is different between the two movies, in the first movie Thanos is a lot calmer and more malevolent in his persueit of the stones almost like he knows he would collect them whereas the Thanos we see from 2014 in Endgame is more aggressive in his nature to get the stones due to the fact that's all he knows and is unaware of his success, again if he had been sent back to his original timeline knowing of his success and then death, that could be why he had no defences surrounding the planet (the garden) that he rested on and almost greeted the avengers and his own death as an old friend that was inevitable. Wait a moment and try again. ;). In the end of the day it was Tony that wanted Bruce to snap everyone back and not change what had happened so why would Tony then go and change the past for another version of himself and not give the alternate version of himself the chance that he had. Reddit, Inc. 2023. You certainly dont leave a dangerous situation, dangerous just because you think theres a chance for things to work out better. Still - reversing the exact thing that severely damaged Thanos must be just a powerful. You can find him on Twitter @TomABacon. Mind-blowing 'Avengers: Endgame' theory says Thanos didn't really kill As a soldier, Paulie was second to none. Avengers: Endgame Proves Hela Is More Powerful Than Thanos, the souls were transported to the Quantum Realm, Marvel Reveals Thanos Has Different Names In Infinity War & Endgame, Ben Afflecks The Flash Costume Concept Looks Way Better Than In The Movie, Henry Cavill vs. David Corenswets Ages Reveal Essential Detail About Superman: Legacys Approach. Update crontab rules without overwriting or duplicating. He destabilized ecosystems across the entire universe, no doubt triggering environmental and ecological catastrophes, and depleted vital resources. The "five years later" time jump is another five years after 2018, when the majority of the film is set, and the film explicitly says that 2014 was "nine years ago." The Blip (also known as the Decimation and the Snap) is a major fictional event depicted in the Marvel Cinematic Universe franchise in which half of all living things in the universe, chosen at random, were exterminated by Thanos snapping his fingers while wearing the Infinity Gauntlet and wielding the Infinity Stones in 2018, and then restored . But one thing is clear. He could not have given it to Thor or anyone else that might have survived snapping the gauntlet because they didn't get it. Meanwhile, the fake stones do have certain powers, but theyre nothing like the real ones: My pet theory regarding how they foil Thanos is by going back in time to gather the MCU universes native Infinity Stones with Infinity Stones while substituting each with Stones borrowed from other universes, so the out of phase substituted Stones from six different universes will fizzle when used together. For moreAvengers: Infinity Warquestions, theories, and speculation, check out these recent articles: Adam Chitwood is the Managing Editor for Collider. Why did Tony Soprano consider killing Paulie? - Quora Their goal is to retrieve the Stones so that they can use them to bring everyone back. Question: Why did Tony stark choose to die when he could have defeated thanos without sacrificing his life? The Blip - Wikipedia The fact thatStephen Strange could see behind the snap, when according to Doctor Strangea sorcerer cannot see beyond death, supports the idea that the snaps didn't really kill at all;the same theoryis also supported by a deleted scene fromAvengers: Endgame, in which the Ancient One said the Infinity Stones could not reverse death - but can still undo the snap. @DJClayworth He knows it's going to hurt him a lot, I doubt he was aware it was 100% going to kill him even if he might suspect. Answer (1 of 5): When Tony Stark did his Snappening the cry of his heart and soul would've been "SEND THAT BIG PURPLE BASTARD AND HIS BASTARD FRIENDS TO HELL!! None of you could survive. [caption id="attachment_705270" align="aligncenter" width="600"], The Russo Brothers Explain Why Scarlet Witch Lost Her Accent in 'Infinity War', Infinity War Directors on Why Those Trailer Scenes Arent in the Movie, Avengers: Infinity War Actor Hints that [Spoiler] Is Really Dead and Gone. Any Don would love to have 100 Paulie Walnuts as his soldiers. 21 Redbeard_1776 1 yr. ago How The End Of Avengers: Endgame Battle, Stones Work At that moment, the enormity of what he is saying is too vast for them to reconcile. He confirmed his suspicions that one of his other children, Black Maw, was dead before speaking to his vision of the universe. Although a couple of years passed since the snap that turned half the universe into dust, the consequences of this could still be felt, and they will surely continue to have an impact in upcoming films. Why doesn't Iron Man's action affect this person in Endgame? Film screener for the Austin Film Festival and holder of passionate opinions e.g. This being giving Thanos the Time Stone. What do you do with graduate students who don't want to work, sit around talk all day, and are negative such that others don't want to be there? Well, movies that involved time traveling can be complex like that. And that logically raises the possibility that Thanos could return. In TikZ, is there a (convenient) way to draw two arrow heads pointing inward with two vertical bars and whitespace between (see sketch)? What's the difference between Hulk's snap and Tony's then? There were other means available to the Illuminati of Earth-838, who defeated their Thanos with the Book of Vishanti, or perhaps that was an option after 15 million potential losses. This would also show why Thanos is different between the two movies, in the first movie Thanos is a lot calmer and more malevolent in his persueit of the stones almost like he knows he would collect them whereas the Thanos we see from 2014 in Endgame is more aggressive in his nature to get the stones due to the fact that's all he knows and is unaware of his success, again if he had been sent back to his original timeline knowing of his success and then death, that could be why he had no defences surrounding the planet (the garden) that he rested on and almost greeted the avengers and his own death as an old friend that was inevitable. Strange uses the Time Stone to see like a lot of possibilities (don't remember exact number) and says that, in only one of them do the Avengers win. How could the dustings from that scene happen an hour (or more) before the Snap? Is Thanos really dead at the end of Avengers: Endgame? murdered) in order to gain one of the infinity stones and enact his plan. A subtle detail in Avengers: Infinity War hints that the snap didn't really kill anyone at all - and implies that Thanos isn't dead. The only problem with his plan is that, according to Thanos, the beauty of his vision was that it was inherently random. So seeing Gamora inside the Soul Stone, does this mean she could be revived in Avengers 4? Yes, half of living things were turned to dust when he snapped that Infinity Gauntlet, but his Infinity Stones might not really be to blame for that. Thanos warns the mage that he will not countenance any betrayals, and an agreement is struck. The physical effect saw bodies, clothing, spacecraft, and objects beingheld by snap victims transformed into dust, and that wasn't just a cool special effect; the lighting in the post-snap world is deliberately darkened, reflecting the fact a large number of particulates had been introduced into the atmosphere, and are preventing some of the sun's radiation reaching the Earth. Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. The substituted Stones will work well enough singly, on a small scale, but as they are out of phase (like Ghost, in a sense), so they will fizzle when used for anything major Like the Snap. The important part of this insight, however, is that if Thanos always kept his word, then when he performed the Snap, he likely did indeed exempt Tony from it specifically since he had told Strange that he would spare Tony's life. The truth is that this probably wasn't intentional; it's the kind of oversight that inevitably slips in when a franchise has been running for over a decade, albeit quite a dramatic example. Avengers: Endgame's ending: explained (spoilers follow) - Vox Plus, is [SPOILER] trapped inside the Soul Stone? More:Marvel Reveals Thanos Has Different Names In Infinity War & Endgame. March 1, 2021 When Iron Man dealt the killing blow to Thanos and his alien army in Avengers: Endgame it just felt right from a narrative perspective. Question: Why did Tony stark choose to die when he could have - Reddit As far-fetched as it may seem, you really should check out the full theory below: [Avengers Endgame] Marvel has punked us all: My long held theory and the KEY FACT that everyone has missed. Defeat Thanos' army conventionally, or just hand off the Gauntlet to The Hulk who can actually survive? Traditional blockbuster storytelling would dictate that the heroes win and the villain is defeated, but what if the villain is the main character of your movie? Its also because of this that their bodies didnt just drop to the ground and stayed there, and the creative team behind Infinity War had to come up with a way to represent this idea on the big screen. One Snap ruined the Hulk; second snap would've killed him. Thanks for contributing an answer to Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange! Is it that hard to conceive that these stones couldn't use there own intelligence to see what Tony had saw and been threw to lock Thanos into one of these "inevitable" loops. All rights reserved. And so he does it, he sacrifices himself: He knows what will happen and he is at peace with it. If Dr Strange knew the outcome why did he put up the fight? He's been working for Collider for over a decade, and in addition to managing content also runs point on crafts interviews, awards coverage, and co-hosts The Collider Podcast with Matt Goldberg (which has been running since 2012). Tony's snap isn't on the same scale to Bruce's or Thanos' and they both survived. Logically, if a person using the Time Stone can't see past their own death, but Doctor Strange could see all the futures that flowed from the snap, it must mean the snap didn't kill people at all. It was do or die at that moment as Thanos has just shrugged all of them off. snaps the Infinity Gauntlet v2, all of Thanos's ships also get disintegrated. Youll notice his arm is damaged post the snap, the gauntlet is damaged post the snap, its the incredible energy required from it and only because of his strength is he able to survive actually using the gauntlet in that capacity. Strange had just raised a finger to Tony to indicate this, why wait on a winning outcome if you're about to win. Shortly thereafter, the melee begins, and their only real hope seems to be Peter Quill's plan. Maria updates Nick with the latest intel. The last piece of evidence centers around one of Thanos' other children. In the midst of the raid on the Avengers' compound, Hawkeye attempts to protect Hulk-gauntlet, but he eventually gives it up to Nebula . It did something else. He saved Tony cause anyone else snapping probably would have just killed team Thanos then you have a time problem. He understands this when he looks at Doctor Strange. Well, its real to Thanos, but none of the people we saw turn to dust actually died. Why does Tony have to snap Thanos and his army to death, wouldn't that create a massive paradox in the timeline because then the original snap Whatever happened in the snaps, one thing is clear: they could be reversed. Reddit, Inc. 2023. Now that you know the end, go back and watch that moment. But this is a second chance. For more information, please see our (It then returns to a darker hue because Thanos' attack on the Avengers Compound kicks up a whole lot of dust in that local area.). InStar Trek, a transporter converts a person or object on a molecular level, transforming them into an energy pattern. Tony knows he is going to die, and also knows that is the only way to end the game. He realises that this is the only one possible winning scenario Doctor Strange saw when he travelled to the future 4 million times. Some fans theorized that thesouls were consumed by the Soul Stone, but that's unlikely, simply because the Soul Stone's destruction would have meant their souls would either have been released or gone for good, unable to be brought back - even by another snap. What's the difference between Hulk's snap and Tony's then? He was waiting for the exact moment to use that high-tech pager. And it is clear that Doctor Strange means for Tony to die, and although Tony does not understand it immediately it seems to me that even the authours assume that he understands it when Strange tells him "if I tell you it won't happen". It had already been established that the Gauntlet can allow for all manner of nuance. If you've got this far thank you haha and please let me know if I'm crazy because this has been blowing around in my head for weeks. Why does the present continuous form of "mimic" become "mimicking"? Tony knew it would kill him because Bruce had said as much prior to his [Hulk's] own snap: 'BRUCE BANNER: You saw what those stones did to Thanos. Just the initial massive landing. However, it is more likely based on the evidence that Strange knew Thanos would keep his word and spare Tony's life, which would mean that he would have had to make an exception when he executed the Snap, singling out Tony specifically and therefore breaking the beauty of his plan. He's done. At the heart of all this is the simple question of what really happened in the two snaps the one inAvengers: Infinity War, and the one inAvengers: Endgame. Cookie Notice Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. Why risk things for longer? Chris Smith has been covering consumer electronics ever since the iPhone revolutionized the industry in 2008. Also this would throwback to infinity war where Thanos says he knows Stark, if he was snapped back to his original timeline then he would have the knowledge of Tony defeating him and would subsequently (as previous videos have shown) try to kill Tony on Titan whereas he only tried to defeat the rest of them and not kill them, maybe Thanos was trying to change his own future by killing Tony and breaking Thanos out of his "inevitable" loop, a loop just like Doctor Strange put Dormammu in. If you buy through a BGR link, we may earn an affiliate commission, helping support our expert product labs. The lighting changes after the Hulk's snap, when Ant-Man looks at the birds, because that dust has been extracted again and used to reform Thanos' victims. Did Tony really kill Thanos : r/MCUTheories - Reddit Joe Russo shared that they thought about the elemental aspect of your body and what happens to it, so the vanishing was a way of accelerating the decomposing process. The plan would have worked, but instead of capitalizing on their advantage, Starlord squanders it by attacking Thanos, dislodging Mantis and her sedating effect from his brow, and the Mad Titan unleashes his full fury against the assembled combatants. Everything I've read, people seem to think that Tony just disappeared them, like Thanos originally did to half of everyone else. Joe Russo confirmed that what we see inside the stone is indeed Gamoras spirit, while also deftly changing the topic of conversation to the damage the Thanos Snap did to Thanos himself: I think its a reflection of [Gamoras] spirit, and the power required to use all of the stones at once is so significant that it sends Thanos into this dream state. The physical bodies of Thanos' snap victims were reduced to dust. This would neatly explain why Doctor Strange could see the ultimate outcome of all these 14 million different futures; because in all but one of them, he would remain in this strange form of stasis forever. Fearless, loyal and tough as nails. When Strange lived through the 14 million branching timelines of Infinity War, the only one he saw where Thanos was defeated was the one where Tony sacrificed himself using the Iron Gauntlet to turn Thanos and his forces to ashes. And of course Tony doesnt know he is going to die by performing the Snap. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. You dont take the football to the goal line and then wait before scoring for no reason. Is there a way to use DNS to block access to my domain? One subtle detail, however, suggests that may not be the case at all - and it has important implications for the end ofAvengers: Endgame. RELATED: Every Marvel Cinematic Universe Phase 4 Movie So Far, Ranked by Critic. Tony's was much more specific than Thanos' since he must have created a carve-out to kill only the Titan's forces and no one else. Even if it would have taken him an additional 5 years it would not matter cause they are time jumping. What Exactly did Tony's snap do Everything I have been reading makes me confused about what Tony did. All rights reserved. RELATED: Doctor Strange 2 Warps WandaVision Into Something More Sinister Than a Tale of Grief. That wasn't just a convenient special effect, either; look closely at the post-snap world ofAvengers: Endgame, and you'll notice that the lighting levels are slightly darker. How could submarines be put underneath very thick glaciers with (relatively) low technology? Everything I have been reading makes me confused about what Tony did. For more information, please see our Tony would have to sacrifice his life, to miss out on his daughter's future. The reason Tony snapped was because of what Strange tells him : I think the bigger question is why a "full" snap is required. When Thanos does actually snap his fingers, the film cuts to this dreamlike world where Thanos confronts the younger version of his daughter Gamorawho he sacrificed (i.e. All rights reserved. ', Even the director Joe Russo says in this interview: 'Avengers: Endgame': The Screenwriters Answer Every Question You Might To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. Why: He used his Infinity Gauntlet containing all the Infinity Stones to snap once more and it took a toll on him, but that second snap didn't dust the remaining half of the universe's. Indeed, that was confirmed byAvengers: Endgame, when the Hulk attempted to take the Time Stone from her. Meanwhile, in the MCU it's now clear that there is such a thing as an immortal soul; that's proven by the existence of the Ancestral Plane inBlack Panther, which T'Challa can visit in order to interact with the spirits of his ancestors. So how was he able to see past his own death? There was no second wave of ships. The Marvel Cinematic Universe reached its peak with Avengers: Infinity War, which brought together all the current superheroes to stop Thanos from collecting all the Infinity Stones, and Avengers: Endgame, where the surviving heroes reversed the snap and defeated the Mad Titan once and for all. and our The decimation that we saw at the end of Avengers: Infinity War wasnt real, according to this theory. How is it that in the Endgame Super Bowl TV spot everyone on Earth are mourning the dead if no one really died? For all he knew he was going to be heavily injured but survive it. Thanos literally erased half the life in the universe - not just sentient beings, but half the plants, animals, and bacteria as well. The Ancient One had protected reality itself by using the Time Stone to explore countless alternate futures, identifying threats and working out how best to deal with them. And also Bruce is only guessing it will kill them, none of them know for sure; they are only guessing based off of two examples who were both Thanos. By this logic, nobody was truly killed when Thanos snapped his fingers; instead, they were shunted into a sort of cosmic cold storage, where they were held in stasis. He certainly. Avengers Endgame: Why No One Else Could've Done Iron Man's Snap We guide our loyal readers to some of the best products, latest trends, and most engaging stories with non-stop coverage, available across all major news platforms. However, it seems to have stored details of their form somewhere, on some plane of reality - perhaps the Quantum Realm. The question is, then, what did the two snaps actually do? Answer (1 of 5): Because he feared Paulie was too stupid and weak to hold up under questioning if ever arrested. Updated Jul 6, 2022 Doctor Strange's vision for a future where the Avengers won saw Iron Man die at the end of Avengers: Endgame, and that might not be a coincidence. Instead, the Avengers from the future went to the past to get the real Infinity Stones and moved all of the people on Earth and other planets into a different plane of existence, maybe the Quantum Realm. Tom Bacon is Head of Screen Rant's Star Wars coverage. If this is the case, then there's no reason to assume Thanos is gone for good from the MCU. 17 17 comments Top Add a Comment cpancoast 1 yr. ago Thanos didn't come back- he came from the past. Strange calls out and tells Thanos that he will give him the Time Stone if he spares Tony's life. And really if they wanted him to come back, they could use the time thing to make him young again like they did to ant man, but he is done. It's entirely possible that, somewhere in the depths of space, some alien races studied into the science behind the snap and worked out what had happened - even managing to reverse it. Its likely similar things happened everywhere on Earth and other planets, meaning that people who have survived the snap may have been killed in the accidents the snap caused. Even if the snap has been faked to mess with Thanos and ultimately beat him, some people will die, Avengers included. Why did Tony Stark have to do the snap? All rights reserved. There's a practical reason why no one else could've done the final snap in Avengers: Endgame other than Iron Man.
Janelle James Parents, 1 Bhk House For Sale In Munnar, Sarasota Law Enforcement Academy, Purpose Of Marriage In The Bible, Articles W